100 Decisive Battles: From Ancient Times to Present

[Pvt. Jaybird]

Hey! What do you know? It lists Inchon (which the Chosin Reservoir was a part of)! But hey, Ebus seems to think he could taken out thousands of ChiComms with a slingshot http://thefirezone.info/forum/images/smilies/rolleyes.gif

http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/tg/detail/-/0195143663/qid=1112367513/sr=1-1/ref=sr_1_1/002-2369004-6802437?v=glance&s=books
http://www.amazon.com/gp/reader/0195143663/ref=sib_rdr_toc/002-2369004-6802437?%5Fencoding=UTF8&p=S002#reader-page

[Biggles of Trinovantes]

Ive got Great Military Blunders by Geoffrey Reagan here, might as well have printed it in French.

[Ebusitanus]

Oh dear good, what a headache...Jay, if instead of wasting you time calling me a commie and what not, you would have actually read what I wrote and WHY I wrote it then perhaps you would make less of a fool of yourself constantly setting up strawmen to attack.

I told you...I did have no freaking clue about the Korean war...ok? based on the information YOU provided I felt like pointing out some issues I found doubtful about.
True enough with post back and forth we came to the point (I would think) that the picture you painted of a division of Marines taking out 12 Chinese divisions at bayonnet point on their own (No aircraft, no artillery, no support troops) was a bit to much flag waving. The discussion (if there was ever one) ended you just insulting me. Whatever buddy.

[Pvt. Jaybird]

Oh dear good, what a headache...Jay, if instead of wasting you time calling me a commie and what not, you would have actually read what I wrote and WHY I wrote it then perhaps you would make less of a fool of yourself constantly setting up strawmen to attack.

I told you...I did have no freaking clue about the Korean war...ok? based on the information YOU provided I felt like pointing out some issues I found doubtful about.
True enough with post back and forth we came to the point (I would think) that the picture you painted of a division of Marines taking out 12 Chinese divisions at bayonnet point on their own (No aircraft, no artillery, no support troops) was a bit to much flag waving. The discussion (if there was ever one) ended you just insulting me. Whatever buddy.

Say, where is that thread? Did you delete it? I'd sure like for people to see what flimsy straw man and/or flat out false arguments you made in it...

[Shane]

How could Culloden get into the Top 100?

[Ebusitanus]

I did not touch any thread of yours..if you would not be such a lazy worm you could easily search for it amongst your own posts. http://thefirezone.info/forum/images/smilies/rolleyes.gif

How could Culloden get into the Top 100?

The same way Inchon got there, check who wrote and for which public it was written and voliá.